
Some links on this page are Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It does not change what we recommend.
The argument is usually framed as a question about the electricity bill. It isn't. For most households the bill difference over a season is a few dollars. The real difference is how much display you can run on one circuit, and there the gap is enormous.
The numbers
| Incandescent | LED | |
|---|---|---|
| Mini bulb | about 0.4 W | well under 0.1 W |
| C7 bulb | about 5 W | under 1 W |
| C9 bulb | about 7 W | under 1 W |
| 100-bulb mini string | about 40 W | a few watts |
| Life | one or two seasons typical | many seasons |
| Chaining | three sets, per CPSC | far more; the box states the limit |
| Colour | warm, familiar, consistent | varies by brand and lens |
| Price per box | lower | higher |
| Breakage | glass filament bulbs | plastic, survives being dropped |
LED figures vary between manufacturers by a factor of two or more, which is why the calculator lets you type in the figure from your own box rather than assuming one.
Why the wattage decides the display
A 15 amp household circuit at 120 volts is rated 1,800 watts. Christmas lights run for more than three hours at a time, which makes them a continuous load, and a continuous load should stay inside 80% of the rating — 1,440 watts.
Now spend that budget:
- Incandescent C9 bulbs at 7 W each. A 25-bulb string draws 175 W. You get eight strings on the circuit. Eight strings of C9 at 12-inch spacing is about 200 feet of roofline — and nothing else.
- LED C9 bulbs at under 1 W. The same 1,440 watts runs the same roofline many times over.
This is why anyone lighting a whole house ends up on LED, regardless of what they think about the colour. It is not frugality. It is that the incandescent version of the same display needs multiple circuits, and most houses do not have spare ones near the front door.
There is a second limit that reinforces it. The Consumer Product Safety Commission advises never stringing together more than three sets of incandescent lights, and no more than three standard-size sets per single extension cord. With incandescents, a long run means multiple cords back to multiple outlets. LED strings routinely state a much higher connected limit on the box, so one run can genuinely be one run.
Run your own numbers
The calculator does the arithmetic on this page for your own measurements — trees, rooflines, columns, railings, shrubs and windows.
Open the calculatorWhere incandescent still wins
Colour, if you care about it. An incandescent bulb glows because a filament is hot, and it produces a continuous spectrum. Warm-toned surfaces — brick, wood, pine needles — look better under it. LEDs produce a narrower spectrum, and cheap ones produce a thin, slightly green or slightly blue white that is immediately recognisable as cheap. Good warm white LEDs with frosted lenses get close. Bad ones are not close at all.
Dimming. Incandescents dim smoothly on an ordinary dimmer. LED strings generally do not, and will flicker or buzz if you try.
Up-front cost. A box of incandescent minis is cheaper than a box of LEDs, and for a single indoor tree that you light for a few weeks a year, the payback calculation for LED is genuinely weak. The case for LED gets strong when the display gets big.
Melting snow. This is a real if niche advantage: the heat of incandescent bulbs keeps them clear of light snow. LEDs will be buried by it.
Where LEDs win beyond the wattage
- They survive storage. Dropping a box of LEDs breaks nothing. Dropping a box of incandescents breaks several.
- One bulb out does not take out the string. Depends on the design, but modern LED strings are usually more forgiving than old series-wired incandescent strings, where a single loose bulb kills a whole section. See why half my lights went out.
- They run cool. Which matters on a dry live tree, on fabric, and anywhere a child will grab them.
- LED light stringsLook for warm white around 2,700 K with frosted lenses if you want the incandescent lookSee options on Amazon
- Incandescent mini light stringsThe traditional glow, for small indoor displays where the current draw does not matterSee options on Amazon
The practical answer
Lighting one indoor tree? Either. Buy whichever colour you like and stop thinking about it.
Lighting the outside of a house? LED. Not for the bill — because the incandescent version of the same display will not fit on the circuits you have.
Replacing a working incandescent display piece by piece? Don't. Mixing old incandescents with new LEDs is the fastest route to a display that looks accidental, because the colour temperatures will not match. Replace a whole zone at a time: the roofline this year, the trees next year.
Last reviewed November 2026.